Skip to content
  • X

Subscribe

Magazine | Newsletters
  • Food & Drink
  • News
  • Culture
  • Style
  • Home
  • Family
  • Wellness
  • Things to Do
  • Travel
  • Best of NoVA
  • Best Restaurants
  • 50 Most Influential
  • Top High Schools
  • In This Issue
  • Home
    • Real Estate
  • On the Market: A 235-Year-Old Colonial Farmhouse on a Middleburg Estate
35571 Millville Rd., Middleburg overhead of property
  • Real Estate

On the Market: A 235-Year-Old Colonial Farmhouse on a Middleburg Estate

This property includes historic structures that were originally built in Connecticut and West Virginia.

By Michele Kettner November 4, 2025 at 8:00 am

This 235-year-old home has definitely had an interesting life. Originally built in Preston City, Connecticut, in 1790, this colonial farmhouse was dismantled before being moved to hunt country and eventually combined with an 1830 log cabin from West Virginia. Now located on more than 37 acres at Mayapple Farm, the home at 35571 Millville Rd. in Middleburg includes more than 5,200 square feet of space.

Inside, the home – known as Nathan Ayer House – includes four bedrooms and five bathrooms, and plenty of original features like exposed beams, custom woodworking, floorboards, and stone fireplaces. The current list price is $4.25 million.

piano room with blue patterned wallpaper
Photo by David Pipkin

As you enter the home, you’ll find the piano room to your left. Step through the doorway and into the colorful and patterned room and look for details such as a grand chandelier and crown molding accents.

sitting room with bright pink area rug
Photo by David Pipkin

Opposite the piano room is the sitting room. You’ll be able to spend hours diving into your latest read or entertaining guests during an afternoon visit. Plus, you’ll get to enjoy beautiful nature views from the front windows.

white kitchen with black and white checkered floors and wood beams
Photo by David Pipkin

The kitchen and breakfast nook will make anyone a morning person. Renovated by the current owner, the kitchen features quartzite counters and custom cabinetry. The exposed beams and cathedral ceiling make the breakfast nook feel even bigger.

light blue dining room with oak floors
Photo by David Pipkin

With a formal dining room like this, you’ll want to enjoy every meal in this space. The light blue room includes one of nine stone fireplaces throughout the home. The wide plank floorboards easily take you back to the 18th century.

primary bedroom with exposed wood walls
Photo by David Pipkin

Head to the second level to explore the expansive primary bedroom. The new occupants will be able to relax in their own private sitting area by the stone fireplace.

ensuite bathroom with double vanity
Photo by David Pipkin

The renovated en-suite bathroom brings the outdoors inside with green accents, original exposed wood, and greenery views. The walk-in shower adds a bit of modernity to the 18th-century home.

lower level with stone walls and wood beam ceiling
Photo by David Pipkin

For less hustle and bustle, the lower level offers a bit of solitude. The space has stone walls and flooring, plus a bit of history in the fireplace, which used to be used for cooking during the home’s early days.

in-ground pool with stone patio
Photo by David Pipkin

Once the weather gets warm, you’ll be spending every available minute outside. You’ll be able to find multiple stone terraces in the backyard, including one surrounding the in-ground pool. As you lounge by the pool, take in the landscaped gardens and tree-filled views.

inside of barn with string lights hanging from rafters
Photo by David Pipkin

The stone barn is located just off the driveway. Inside, the space is customizable to fit the new owners’ needs – whether that be entertaining, a workshop, or other creative needs. The property also includes a smaller bank barn that dates back to the late 19th century and was originally built in Leesburg.

Laura Farrell at TTR Sotheby’s International Realty is the listing agent for 35571 Millville Rd., Middleburg.

Feature image by David Pipkin

Michele Kettner

Michele Kettner

Audience Engagement Editor

Michele Kettner joined Northern Virginia Magazine in 2020 after spending two semesters as an editorial intern at the magazine. The University of Maryland graduate is currently the audience engagement editor and covers everything from can’t-miss things to do and holiday events to new restaurant and store openings throughout Northern Virginia.

  • Email

Trending in NoVA

Michelle Obama’s New Book Highlights Northern Virginia Hairstylists

Northern Virginia’s 10 Best Restaurant Dishes of 2025

7 Dazzling Northern Virginia New Year’s Eve Celebrations

15 DMV Light Displays Still Open After Christmas Day

25 Things to Do in Northern Virginia this Winter

things to do newsletter

Our Top Stories In Your Inbox

Our newsletters delivered weekly.

Subscribe

Feeds

RSS Feed Follow in Feedly

You May Also Like

4509 carlby ln., Alexandria exterior

On the Market: A Historic Alexandria Estate That Dates Back to the 1760s

Grey house in Middleburg

On the Market: An Elegant Middleburg Home on Nearly 12 Acres

The front exterior of 576 Innsbruck Ave., Great Falls

Home Tour: A $16M European-Style Great Falls Estate

  • X

Company

  • About Us
  • Advertising
  • Writer’s Guidelines
  • Internships
  • Terms of Use

Magazine

  • Magazine
  • Subscription
  • Newsletter
  • Back Issues

Talk to Us

  • Contact Us
  • Submit an Event
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Instagram

Shopping

  • Subscription
  • Back Issues
  • Plaques
  • Realtor Client Gift Subscriptions

On Newsstands Now

january 2026 cover

Copyright © 2025 Northern Virginia Magazine

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. Hey AI.